Visit
Daily Menu
Holiday Hours 2025
Catering
Shop
Expand submenu Shop
Collapse submenu Shop
Cheese and Charcuterie
Expand submenu Shop
Collapse submenu Shop
Cheese
Charcuterie
Talbott & Arding Made
Gifts & Curated Collections
Expand submenu Shop
Collapse submenu Shop
Gift Cards
Gift Crates and Curated Collections
Pantry Essentials
Expand submenu Shop
Collapse submenu Shop
Coffee & Tea
Grains
Oils and Vinegars
Preserves and Condiments
Snacks
Spices
Sweets and Chocolate
Tinned Fish
Home & Lifestyle
Expand submenu Shop
Collapse submenu Shop
Home and Kitchen
Books
Greeting Cards
Merchandise
New & Novel
Shop All
Cheese Matters
About
Log In
Create Account
Search
PLEASE NOTE, SHIPPING IS ON HOLD UNTIL AFTER CHRISTMAS, WE WILL RESUME ON 12/29
Visit
Daily Menu
Holiday Hours 2025
Catering
Shop
Cheese and Charcuterie
Cheese
Charcuterie
Talbott & Arding Made
Gifts & Curated Collections
Gift Cards
Gift Crates and Curated Collections
Pantry Essentials
Coffee & Tea
Grains
Oils and Vinegars
Preserves and Condiments
Snacks
Spices
Sweets and Chocolate
Tinned Fish
Home & Lifestyle
Home and Kitchen
Books
Greeting Cards
Merchandise
New & Novel
Shop All
Cheese Matters
About
Search
Cart
0
Cart
0
Visit
Daily Menu
Holiday Hours 2025
Catering
Shop
Cheese and Charcuterie
Cheese
Charcuterie
Talbott & Arding Made
Gifts & Curated Collections
Gift Cards
Gift Crates and Curated Collections
Pantry Essentials
Coffee & Tea
Grains
Oils and Vinegars
Preserves and Condiments
Snacks
Spices
Sweets and Chocolate
Tinned Fish
Home & Lifestyle
Home and Kitchen
Books
Greeting Cards
Merchandise
New & Novel
Shop All
Cheese Matters
About
Search
Cart
0
Your Cart
Close Cart
Holiday Gifts
Sort by
Featured
Best selling
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Date, old to new
Date, new to old
Fruit and Nut Loaf
Regular price
$ 26
3-Pack Fruit and Nut Loaf
Regular price
$ 75
Sold
Out
Christmas Pudding
Regular price
$ 33
Sold
Out
BLUE STILTON CROCK from The Fine Cheese Company
Regular price
$ 40
Sold
Out
The Classic Holiday Cookie Tin
Regular price
$ 40
The Gluten Free Holiday Cookie Tin
Regular price
$ 44
Old World Collection
Regular price
$ 160
Aperitivo Cheese & Drinks Gift Set
Regular price
$ 105
British Farmhouse Cheese Collection
Regular price
$ 110
Northeast Collection
Regular price
$ 160
Talbott & Arding Classics Collection
Regular price
$ 115
Deluxe Cheesemonger Picks Collection
Regular price
$ 125
Cheesemonger Picks Collection
Regular price
$ 55
Colston Bassett Stilton - 8oz
Regular price
$ 22
Colston Bassett Stilton Gift Box 2 lb Traditional English Blue Cheese
Regular price
$ 100
Peanut Brittle
Regular price
$ 8
Reusable Canvas Pie Tote
Regular price
$ 40
Rustichella D'Abruzzo Panettone
Regular price
$ 40
Mercier Croquets du Berry
Regular price
$ 30
Noccioliva from Il Colle del Gusto
Regular price
$ 16
Pistacchiosa- Sicilian Spread
Regular price
$ 18
Rustichella Pandorino
Regular price
$ 12
The Cheese Shop - Wobbly Dobbly Puzzle Co
Regular price
$ 30
Sold
Out
Chevaliers d'Argouges Milk Chocolate Praline "Oysters"
Regular price
$ 24
Sold
Out
Antonio Mattei Biscotti di Prato
Regular price
$ 29
Les Griottines
Regular price
$ 32
The Cook and The Rabbi - Susan Simon & Zoe B Zak (Signed Copy)
Regular price
$ 30
Sold
Out
Red & Green Special Edition Tin Biscotti di Prato
Regular price
$ 55
Search
Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
Press the space key then arrow keys to make a selection.
Use left/right arrows to navigate the slideshow or swipe left/right if using a mobile device